. . . It is up to the try on to decide who is guilty and who is innocent. If, therefore, a calculate is honest, then the people in his district depart be at pink of my John; and if the people be at peace, their manners and morals will be good. All vagabonds and idlers, all spreaders of false rumors and all agitate makers will disappear (5).
This claim is, of course, preposterous, for there has never been such a peaceful, crime-free city, and, if there were, there would be no regard for the judge. Nevertheless(prenominal), true or not, the statement makes clear that the judge has wicked violence to at least frighten the people. The judge is seen as a legal extension of the divine law of Heaven. In fact, the author suggests, "His motto should be: 'To demonstrate clearly the just retribution meted out by Heaven, never failing in its hair-fine accuracy'" (6).
Of course, for all intents and purposes, despite claims about oversight from higher semipolitical places, despite claims about the role of open opinion and juridical review, the judge is essentially a god in his re
Here prove Dee commences the torture of a helpless charr--murderer or not--and his primary concern is losing his job and acquire a bad reputation. Those fears do not stop him from having the woman beaten while stripped naked in public court, and, when that failed to bring the desired confession, then put into a gondola which crushes her hands.
"You, woman, dare to defy me right here in this court? Now I shall
alm, deciding himself what is heavenly retribution, what is "hair-fine accuracy.
" The book portrays Judge Dee as an eccentric but lovable and wise instance wandering about the countryside in disguises in order to tucker out to the truth of the case at hand. He may be such a character much of the time, especially external the courtroom, but once he returns to his official domain, his true power can be exercised in all its demonic horror. In the justice system as portrayed in this book, the judge can do whatever he feels he need to do to extract a confession from the accused. Judge Dee in one case demands a confession from the accused, who proclaims her innocence. The eminent judge responds:
The book describes a justice system which is built and thrives on the torturing of helpless human beings. It matters not that the protagonist of the book is a man with a fascinating mind, for that mind relies eventually not on intuition but on the god-like power the law gives him in extracting the needed confessions from the defendants before him. It matters not whether the defendants are guilty or not, for a justice system which depends on torture for its results can hardly be called human, much less just.
Order your essay at Orderessay and get a 100% original and high-quality custom paper within the required time frame.
No comments:
Post a Comment